Why is it so hard? Seriously.
This is a question that was asked in a recent blog post by arts education leader and advocate Matt D’Arrigo, his response to being surrounded by a preponderance of evidence about the benefits of arts education, and the seemingly overwhelming support for arts education by average Americans (93% of Americans believe it’s important, according to Americans for the Arts), and still feeling he was rolling a boulder up a hill.
“Yet here we still stand; hands out begging for change–both literally and figuratively.”
His question is one that rattles around in my brain almost daily. as I hear the same story over and over: lack of money, lack of supplies, lack of qualified instructors, lack of time, lack, lack, lack from teachers, administrators, parents, and colleagues across the country.
All of us are rolling that boulder up a hill. Our Artists in Schools and Communities program ran out of funding two months into the fiscal year, for the second year in a row, due to budget cuts. The worst part of my job is telling a teacher or artist who calls me I have no money to fund their program this school year that isn’t half over yet. Sometimes it is too hard, especially when I have to tell it to a school with no arts specialists, with a population of kids who don’t have the resources to take after school arts classes either because they are expensive or they live too far away from any.
And then, as has happened so many times before, a teacher inspires me to keep going. Jennifer Magiera teaches in the Chicago Public Schools, and gave this talk at a Tedx event. It’s long, but it’s worth it if you have 18 minutes:
Magiera talks about a lot of good things related to arts education, like the power of purposeful play, and how we can’t just expect kids to know how to use their creative skills if we don’t give them any opportunity to practice them in the classroom. She talks about how opportunities to use creative thinking in the classroom gives kids the skills they need to “outwit obstacles” in life. I love that! She also talks about how she wanted to transform her teaching to give her students more opportunities to be creative, and how overwhelming it felt to her because she waited too long and the change was very hard to make, but she managed the change by focusing on the “bright spots.” She defined bright spots as small things that are working, and these small things help not to let the big things overwhelm you.
Change is hard, and slow, and daunting. But, Magiera is right, it is not hard to find bright spots. In arts education in Montana, we have so many! Here are a few that I have encountered, just in recent memory:
- UM Dance Professor Karen Kaufmann and Missoula-based dance educator Jordan Dehline just published an incredible resource for teachers called Dance Integration: 36 Dance Lesson Plans for Science and Mathematics (available at www.HumanKinetics.com). These lessons have been field tested in Montana classrooms by the CoMotion Dance Project with Montana classroom teachers. They work! I’ve seen them in action.
- In October the Montana Music Educator’s Association (MMEA) held their annual conference at Hellgate High School in Missoula. I spoke briefly at their general session, which opened with bandmasters from all over the state playing a newly-commissioned piece in honor of our great state. And have you ever heard an auditorium packed with music teachers sing the national anthem together? I highly recommend the spine-tingling experience. The energy in the room was through the roof. We have remarkable music educators in the Big Sky–they love music, and they love young people.
- The VSA Montana Choir sang during the MEA-MFT conference across town that same day. The choir is made up of some 40 adults with disabilities–but their choir director doesn’t treat them like they have disabilities. We watched their rehearsal, where they warmed up, he gave them notes, he corrected them and made them do it again–just like any choir. And they sang with a sense of joy that lifted the spirits of every person in the room.
- This past summer, Montana Quarterly published an article about Bynum School, one of 61 one-room schoolhouses in Montana. At Bynum school, they have an 80-year-old tradition of beginning each and every day by dancing. One of the most beautiful articles I’ve every come across about arts education, and Montana, I have not stopped thinking about it. I hope someday soon to meet their remarkable teacher, Susan Luinstra.
I’d love to hear about your bright spot in arts education. Every bright spot helps add some light, and makes the hard part, the non-stop struggle to keep arts education accessible to every student, a little less daunting.